News

Adapting frugality to local constraints

Can energy conservation be implemented in Martinique in the same way as in mainland France? A study published in June 2026, conducted by KPMG Public Sector on behalf of ADEME, estimates that the island’s economic, social, and regional realities require a tailored approach. Purchasing power, mobility, food, land use, and access to resources, among other factors, place social justice at the heart of the discussion.


 

A sense of restraint that cannot simply be transposed

According to ADEME, energy efficiency is «an approach aimed at reexamining individual and collective needs.».

It must lead to changes in lifestyles and production methods in order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and pressure on resources, while pursuing goals of social equity and the public interest.

However, the study highlights a key distinction for overseas territories: Moderation must be a conscious choice and cannot be equated with a restriction imposed by financial insecurity. Reduced consumption due to a lack of financial resources does not, therefore, fall under the category of frugality according to this definition.

This distinction takes on particular significance in Martinique, where economic and social constraints remain significant. The study thus concludes that a just transition requires adapting public policies to households’ actual capabilities and to the region’s specific characteristics.

High Cost of Living and Addictions at the Heart of the Equation

The picture painted by the report helps to gauge these constraints. Martinique had 355,000 residents as of January 1, 2025, with a declining population of 0.7 % per year on average between 2016 and 2022.

The poverty rate has reached 26,7 %, while prices were, according to the data cited in the study, 13.8 % higher than in mainland France. The unemployment rate stood at 12.4 1Q3Q in 2024.

Added to this is a heavy reliance on imports. The report describes an economy that is largely service-based and also highlights the vulnerabilities in food and energy self-sufficiency.

In this context, changing consumer behavior does not depend solely on individual decisions: the available supply, prices, and infrastructure largely determine the available options.

Create the right conditions before changing behaviors

This is one of the study’s key findings. According to the authors, moderation cannot rely solely on recommendations directed at individuals.

Mobility provides a concrete example of this. Reducing the role of the car requires that real alternatives actually exist:

  • accessible public transportation;
  • carpooling;
  • active transportation, such as walking or biking;
  • local services;
  • a different approach to commuting.

The same reasoning applies to energy, water, food, and land use planning. Local governments and public officials therefore play a crucial role in create an environment in which moderate behavior becomes possible, rather than placing the burden solely on households.

This approach is all the more important given that the term itself remains difficult to gain acceptance for. Outside the energy and land sectors, the stakeholders interviewed tend to use the concepts of resilience, efficiency, optimization, frugality, or the circular economy.

However, the definition proposed by ADEME is considered relevant by nearly all of the stakeholders interviewed, but too technical to be used as is when communicating with the general public.

Practices Already in Place in Martinique

The study also shows that sustainability is not merely a concept to be introduced in the region. Several initiatives in Martinique are already putting some of its principles into practice.

With Madin’Friches, EPF Martinique, DEAL, and ADEME are thus working to repurpose already urbanized areas. The report identifies 630 designated brownfield sites, shared with municipalities and intermunicipal organizations, while feasibility studies are to be conducted on about 20 priority sites.

One of the main goals is to reuse existing land rather than expand urban development into natural or agricultural areas.

In the food industry, VACATION RENTALS, led by the Territorial Collectivity of Martinique, uses school meal programs and public procurement to promote more local, healthy, and sustainable food sourcing, while supporting agricultural sectors.

In Le Lamentin, Fabrik 3.60 illustrates another aspect of this transition. This low-tech fablab, run by the nonprofit La Sphère, organizes workshops focused on reuse, repairability, and the use of existing resources, with solutions tailored to local realities.

Talking about autonomy rather than deprivation

Ultimately, the study calls for a reevaluation of how moderation is presented in Martinique. Rather than associating it solely with a reduction in consumption, the authors suggest placing greater emphasis on:

  • the territory's autonomy;
  • the savings achieved;
  • health;
  • the protection of local resources;
  • resilience;
  • improving the quality of life.

The issue at hand, therefore, is not so much to ask the people of Martinique to «making do with less» rather than simply creating the conditions that allow us to consume, produce, travel, and plan our communities in different ways.

From this perspective, frugality becomes less a policy of restriction and more a tool for reducing certain dependencies and strengthening the region’s capacity for action.


You can view it here The study conducted by KPMG Public Sector on behalf of ADEME—Adapting Resource Efficiency to Overseas Territories: Challenges, Practices, and Leverage Points for Action

Related Articles

Back to top button